MadTeach

MadTeach got its name because I used to teach in Madison, WI, and that used to make me pretty mad...now I teach in a large city... totally different scene... but I'm keeping the name. :-)

Disclaimer: Links to other websites DO NOT imply support for all content or opinions on these sites!

Sunday, May 15, 2005

the importance of structure & expectation in comprehension

Why do we organize writing in conventional ways? Partly so readers know how to interpret it, how to anticipate what comes next and how it fits with what they've read already.

This concept is essential both for readers and writers.

One possible way to convey that: blues songs.

Blues songs often repeat a line about an ordinary event or occurrence, and only at the end of the stanza (wc?) do they hit you with the significance of the event.

Like this one from Robert Johnson:
I'm gointa get up in the mornin
I believe I'll dust my broom
I'm gointa get up in the mornin
I believe I'll dust my broom
Girlfriend the black man you've been lovin
girlfriend can get my room


People who are familiar with the structure know that the first few lines are a setup, and they wait for the knockout punch in the last line.

If you didn't know anything about blues, you might get bored after the first few bars, thinking, "this song is just about cleaning."

Somehow, I can use this to teach about writing structure....... this is the part that always stumps me. I get a good analogy, but then how do I show students how to transfer it over to their own writing and reading?

I think usually I'm too impatient. I need to spend more time with the analogy first.

You only need one good idea per lesson. But you need to stick with that good idea til it really sinks in.

2 Comments:

At 10:23 PM, Blogger goblinbox said...

Best writing teacher I ever had used lots of Mark Twain quotes about writing, like the one about how a good writer does "all the work" so that the reader doesn't have to. Twain makes reading so easy for the reader, and I think that's a concept writers do well to keep in mind: my goal is not just to say something, but to say it so well that it slips into my reader's head without her having to do much to get it there!

 
At 4:21 PM, Blogger birdfarm said...

I like that--thank you! At a conference I just attended, a speaker talked about how hip hop poetry "paints pictures with words." This is a good "launching" point too. Always relate new information to something the students are familiar with... in the quote you give, just the simple concept of "doing work."

 

Post a Comment

<< Home